Identify and explain the two points that highlight the nature of principles of management, in the above case.
Identify and explain the two points that highlight the nature of principles of management, in the above case.
Official answer
The two points highlighting the nature of principles of management in this case are:
- Universal applicability (with a flexible extent of application): Rajiv believes management principles can be applied to both 'Tako Solutions' (a software firm) and 'Sabka Mart Retail' (a supermarket chain), showing that the principles are universally applicable to all kinds of organisations. However, the case also notes the extent of application will differ because the nature of work, scale of operations, and business activities of the two companies are not the same — showing that while universal, principles must be applied flexibly, considering each organisation's specific situation.
- General guidelines, not readymade solutions: Rajiv knows the principles 'would not provide readymade solutions' because real-world situations at the two companies are 'complex and dynamic'. Yet he believes 'even small guidelines could help in solving many problems' — showing that principles of management only provide broad, adaptable guidance for managers to think through problems, not exact, off-the-shelf answers.
Marking scheme
- 1.1 mark for identifying 'Universal Applicability' + 1 mark for explaining it with case reference (applies to both companies but extent of application differs).
- 2.1 mark for identifying 'General Guidelines, not readymade solutions' + 1 mark for explaining it with case reference (complex/dynamic situations, yet guidelines help).
Hint
Look for two case-clues: 'applied as much to... though the extent... will differ' (universal but flexible extent) and 'would not provide readymade solutions... even small guidelines could help' (general guidelines, not exact solutions).
Quick oral answer
The case shows universal applicability — principles apply to both companies but to a differing extent — and that principles are only general guidelines, not exact readymade solutions, for complex real-world situations.
Common mistakes
- 1.Stating 'universal applicability' without explaining that the extent/degree of application varies with organisational context.
- 2.Confusing 'general guidelines' with 'flexible' — though related, the case specifically emphasises principles are NOT readymade solutions, a distinct nuance from flexibility of application.
- 3.Picking unrelated nature-points (e.g. 'behavioural in nature') that are not supported by any specific line in the case.
Analysis and explanation
This case tests the nature of principles of management, a set of characteristics distinguishing management principles from principles in pure/exact sciences.
Concept: NCERT lists several features of nature — universal applicability, general guidelines, formed by practice and experimentation, flexible, mainly behavioural, cause-and-effect relationship, and contingent. This case is deliberately built to test exactly two of these: universal applicability (same principles, different organisations, different extent) and general guidelines (principles guide but don't dictate solutions).
Exam trap: Students often state 'universal applicability' without explaining the crucial qualifier that the extent of application varies with the organisation's context — the case explicitly tests this nuance, since simply saying 'principles apply everywhere' misses half the marks. Similarly, for the second point, students should avoid simply writing 'principles are flexible' when the case specifically emphasises they are 'general guidelines, not readymade solutions' — a more precise phrasing that must be used to score full marks.
Interesting facts
NCERT lists seven features under the 'nature of principles of management': universal applicability, general guidelines, formed by practice/experimentation, flexible, mainly behavioural, cause-and-effect relationships, and contingent.
Henri Fayol himself described his fourteen principles as flexible rather than rigid, stating that 'there is nothing rigid or absolute in management affairs.'
Question details
Q31 of 37 questions
- Board
- CBSE
- Class
- Class 12
- Subject
- Business Studies
- Year
- 2026
- Section
- Section C
- Marks
- 4
- Chapter
- Principles of Management
- Topic
- Nature of Principles of Management
- Bloom's level
- analyze
- Syllabus topic
- Unit 2: Principles of Management — Nature of Principles (Universal Applicability; General Guidelines)
- Author
- CBSE
- Reviewed by
- Padhantu Academic Team
Spotted a mistake or something unclear?
Tell us and we will fix it.
Frequently asked questions
Why is 'universal applicability' qualified by 'extent may differ'?
Because organisations differ in size, nature of work, and complexity, the same management principle (e.g., division of work) may need to be applied differently — universal does not mean identical application everywhere.
How are principles of management different from principles of pure science?
Unlike the fixed, exact principles of physics or chemistry, management principles are general guidelines developed from human behaviour and experience — they must be adapted to each situation and do not guarantee a single correct outcome.