Q28
4 marksSection B

Read the following passage and answer the questions given below: Most of metals occur in combined state in form of ores. Carbonate ores are converted into oxides by calcination and sulphide ores by roasting. Oxides are reduced with suitable reducing agent like carbon to get free metal. Highly reactive metals like Al, Mg are also used as reducing agents to obtain metal from their oxides. Most reactive metals are obtained by electrolytic reduction of their molten ores. Alloying is a very good method of improving the properties of a metal. We can get desired properties by this method. The electrical conductivity and melting point of an alloy is less than that of pure metals. (a) Why carbonate or sulphide ores are converted to oxides before extraction of metal from it? (b) Write a reaction in which Aluminium is used as a reducing agent to obtain metal from its oxide. (c) (i) How is copper obtained from its ore (Cu2S\mathrm{Cu_2S})? Give equations of the reactions. OR (c) (ii) (I) Why highly reactive metals cannot be obtained from their oxides by using carbon as a reducing agent? (II) Why solder, an alloy of lead and tin, is used for welding electrical wires together?

Metals and Non-metals
Extraction and refining of metals; alloys
Official Answer

(a) Why carbonate/sulphide ores are converted to oxides before extraction:

It is easier to obtain a metal from its oxide than from its sulphide or carbonate ore. Sulphide ores are converted to oxides by roasting (heating strongly in excess air), and carbonate ores by calcination (heating strongly in limited air). The resulting oxides can then be reduced to the free metal using a suitable reducing agent such as carbon.


(b) Aluminium as a reducing agent (thermit reaction):

Fe2O3(s)+2Al(s)2Fe(l)+Al2O3(s)+Heat\mathrm{Fe_2O_3(s) + 2Al(s) \rightarrow 2Fe(l) + Al_2O_3(s) + Heat}

This highly exothermic displacement reaction (the thermit reaction) produces molten iron and is used to join railway tracks or cracked machine parts.


(c)(i) Extraction of copper from Cu2S\mathrm{Cu_2S}:

Copper is low in the reactivity series, so its sulphide ore can be converted directly to the metal by heating in air (self-reduction):

2Cu2S+3O2(g)Heat2Cu2O(s)+2SO2(g)\mathrm{2Cu_2S + 3O_2(g) \xrightarrow{Heat} 2Cu_2O(s) + 2SO_2(g)}

2Cu2O+Cu2SHeat6Cu(s)+SO2(g)\mathrm{2Cu_2O + Cu_2S \xrightarrow{Heat} 6Cu(s) + SO_2(g)}

In the first step, some Cu2S\mathrm{Cu_2S} is oxidised to Cu2O\mathrm{Cu_2O} by heating in air; in the second step, the remaining Cu2S\mathrm{Cu_2S} reduces this Cu2O\mathrm{Cu_2O} to give metallic copper along with SO2\mathrm{SO_2}.


OR (c)(ii):

(I) Highly reactive metals (like Na, Mg, Ca, Al) cannot be obtained from their oxides using carbon as the reducing agent because these metals have a greater affinity for oxygen than carbon does — carbon cannot displace them from their oxides. Such metals are instead obtained by electrolytic reduction of their molten compounds (e.g., molten chlorides or, for aluminium, molten oxide).


(II) Solder (an alloy of lead and tin) is used for welding electrical wires together because it has a low melting point. This allows it to melt easily at temperatures that do not damage the wire's insulation, flow into and bond the joint, and then solidify to form a strong electrical and mechanical connection.

Marking Scheme

  • 1(a) Correct reason (oxide easier to reduce) with naming of roasting and calcination — 1 mark
  • 2(b) Correct balanced thermit reaction — 1 mark
  • 3(c)(i) Both correct equations for extraction of Cu from Cu2S — 2 marks; OR (c)(ii)(I) correct reasoning on affinity for oxygen — 1 mark, (II) correct reasoning on low melting point of solder — 1 mark

Hint

For (a), think about which is simpler to reduce chemically: an oxide, sulphide, or carbonate. For (c)(ii), recall the reactivity-series argument for why carbon fails to reduce certain oxides.

Analysis & Explanation

The chapter states directly: "It is easier to obtain a metal from its oxide, as compared to its sulphides and carbonates. Therefore, prior to reduction, the metal sulphides and carbonates must be converted into metal oxides," naming roasting and calcination as the respective conversion processes. It also gives the thermit reaction explicitly: Fe2O3(s)+2Al(s)2Fe(l)+Al2O3(s)+Heat\mathrm{Fe_2O_3(s) + 2Al(s) \rightarrow 2Fe(l) + Al_2O_3(s) + Heat}, used to join railway tracks. For copper, the text gives the exact two-step self-reduction sequence for Cu2S\mathrm{Cu_2S} (heating in air converts some to Cu2O\mathrm{Cu_2O}, which is then reduced by the remaining Cu2S\mathrm{Cu_2S} to give free copper and SO2\mathrm{SO_2}) since copper, being low in the reactivity series, can be extracted by heating alone. For the alternative sub-part, the chapter explains: "carbon cannot reduce the oxides of sodium, magnesium, calcium, aluminium, etc.,... because these metals have more affinity for oxygen than carbon," which is why electrolytic reduction is used for highly reactive metals instead. Finally, the chapter explicitly states solder "has a low melting point and is used for welding electrical wires together," grounding part (II).

Common Mistakes

  1. 1Confusing roasting (sulphide ores, excess air) with calcination (carbonate ores, limited air), or reversing which conditions apply to which.
  2. 2Writing the thermit reaction with wrong stoichiometry or omitting that it is exothermic/produces molten iron.
  3. 3In (c)(i), forgetting the two-step self-reduction process and instead writing a generic carbon-reduction equation, which does not apply to Cu2S.
  4. 4In (c)(ii)(I), giving a vague answer like 'they are too reactive' without linking it to affinity for oxygen compared to carbon.
  5. 5In (c)(ii)(II), confusing solder's low melting point with high electrical conductivity as the reason for its use.

Interesting Facts

The thermit reaction can reach temperatures above 2500^\circC, hot enough to melt iron on the spot — this is why it is used for on-site rail welding.

Copper's self-reduction from Cu2S is one of the oldest metallurgical processes known, dating back thousands of years, since copper's low reactivity makes it one of the easiest metals to extract.

Spotted a mistake or something unclear?

Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many marks does this question carry in CBSE Class 10 Science 2026?

This question carries 4 marks in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2026 examination.

Which chapter does this question come from in Science?

This question is from the chapter "Metals and Non-metals" in the CBSE Class 10 Science syllabus.

What topic does this question cover in Science?

This question covers the topic "Extraction and refining of metals; alloys" from CBSE Class 10 Science.

What type of question is this in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2026 paper?

This question appears in Section B in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2026 paper.