Q33
3 marksShort AnswerSection C

(a) (i) Why does a kitchen garden called an artificial ecosystem while a forest is considered to be a natural ecosystem? (ii) While designing an artificial ecosystem at home, write any two things to be kept in mind to convert it into a self-sustaining system. Give reason to justify your answer. OR (b) (i) Construct a food chain of four trophic levels comprising the following: Hawk, snake, plants, rat. (ii) 20,000 J of energy was transferred by the producers to the organism of second trophic level. Calculate the amount of energy that will be transferred by organisms of the third trophic level to the organisms of the fourth trophic level.

Our Environment
Ecosystems and Energy Flow
Official Answer

Option (a)


(i) Difference between Kitchen Garden and Forest:

  • Kitchen Garden (Artificial Ecosystem): It is a human-made ecosystem. Humans select the plants, prepare the soil, water them, and actively maintain the system. It lacks natural self-regulation and diversity.
  • Forest (Natural Ecosystem): It is a natural, self-sustaining ecosystem that operates and maintains its balance without any human intervention.

(ii) Designing a Self-Sustaining Artificial Ecosystem:

To make an artificial ecosystem (like an aquarium or terrarium) self-sustaining, we must include:

  1. Producers (e.g., green plants/aquatic plants): They capture solar energy to perform photosynthesis, producing organic food and releasing oxygen.
  2. Decomposers (e.g., bacteria and fungi): They break down dead organic matter and waste products into simple inorganic substances, returning nutrients to the soil/water for reuse by plants.

  • Reason: Without producers, consumers will have no food or oxygen. Without decomposers, dead remains and waste will accumulate, and natural replenishment of nutrients will stop, causing the ecosystem to collapse.



Option (b)


(i) Food Chain Construction:

The food chain consisting of the given organisms across four trophic levels is:

Plants (Producers)Rat (Primary Consumer)Snake (Secondary Consumer)Hawk (Tertiary Consumer)\text{Plants (Producers)} \rightarrow \text{Rat (Primary Consumer)} \rightarrow \text{Snake (Secondary Consumer)} \rightarrow \text{Hawk (Tertiary Consumer)}


(ii) Energy Calculation:

According to Lindeman's 10% Law of Energy Transfer, only 10%10\% of the energy available at one trophic level is transferred to the next level.

  • Energy transferred to the 2nd2^{\text{nd}} trophic level (Rat) = 20,000 J20,000\text{ J}
  • Energy transferred to the 3rd3^{\text{rd}} trophic level (Snake) = 10% of 20,000 J=10100×20,000=2,000 J10\% \text{ of } 20,000\text{ J} = \frac{10}{100} \times 20,000 = 2,000\text{ J}
  • Energy transferred to the 4th4^{\text{th}} trophic level (Hawk) = 10% of 2,000 J=10100×2,000=200 J10\% \text{ of } 2,000\text{ J} = \frac{10}{100} \times 2,000 = 200\text{ J}

Therefore, the amount of energy transferred by the organisms of the third trophic level (Snake) to the fourth trophic level (Hawk) is 200 J200\text{ J}.



artificial ecosystemnatural ecosystemproducersdecomposersself-sustaining10% lawtrophic levelPlants -> Rat -> Snake -> Hawk200 J

Marking Scheme

  • 1For Option (a):
  • 21 Mark: Correctly distinguishing between kitchen garden (artificial/human-made) and forest (natural).
  • 31 Mark: Identifying producers and decomposers as the two essential components to make it self-sustaining.
  • 41 Mark: Providing the correct justification (producers make food/oxygen, decomposers recycle nutrients).
  • 5OR
  • 6For Option (b):
  • 71 Mark: Correctly constructing the food chain: Plants -> Rat -> Snake -> Hawk.
  • 81 Mark: Calculating energy at the 3rd trophic level (2,000 J).
  • 91 Mark: Calculating energy at the 4th trophic level (200 J) with proper steps.

Hint

For (a): Think about who maintains a garden versus a forest, and what roles plants and microbes play in keeping an aquarium clean and alive. For (b): Arrange the organisms in the order of 'who eats whom'. Then, divide the energy by 10 for each step you move up the food chain.

Quick Oral Answer

A kitchen garden is artificial because it is managed by humans, whereas a forest is natural and self-regulating. In a food chain of Plants -> Rat -> Snake -> Hawk, if 20,000 J is at the second level (Rat), then the third level (Snake) gets 2,000 J, and the fourth level (Hawk) gets 200 J due to the 10% law.

Analysis & Explanation

This question tests two core concepts:

  1. Ecosystem classification and sustainability: Students must distinguish between natural and human-made ecosystems based on human intervention. They must also understand that a self-sustaining ecosystem requires both producers (for energy input) and decomposers (for nutrient recycling).
  2. Trophic levels and the 10% Law of Energy Transfer: Students must construct a logical food chain based on predator-prey relationships (Plants -> Rat -> Snake -> Hawk) and apply Lindeman's 10% law sequentially to find the energy at the fourth trophic level.

Common Mistakes

  1. 1In (a), forgetting to mention decomposers as a key component for self-sustainability.
  2. 2In (b)(i), writing the food chain in the wrong order (e.g., starting with Hawk or putting Snake before Rat).
  3. 3In (b)(ii), applying the 10% law incorrectly (e.g., multiplying by 10 instead of taking 10%, or skipping a trophic level).

Interesting Facts

Because of the 10% law, energy decreases so rapidly that most food chains rarely exceed 4 to 5 trophic levels, as there is simply not enough energy left to support higher levels.

Spotted a mistake or something unclear?

Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many marks does this question carry in CBSE Class 10 Science 2023?

This question carries 3 marks in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2023 examination.

Which chapter does this question come from in Science?

This question is from the chapter "Our Environment" in the CBSE Class 10 Science syllabus.

What topic does this question cover in Science?

This question covers the topic "Ecosystems and Energy Flow" from CBSE Class 10 Science.

What type of question is this in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2023 paper?

This is a Short Answer question from Section C in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2023 paper.