Assertion (A): The needle of a magnetic compass kept in strong external magnetic field, always aligns itself in north-south direction on the earth.
Reason (R): Behaviour of the needle of a compass is same as that of a freely suspended bar magnet.
Assertion (A): The needle of a magnetic compass kept in strong external magnetic field, always aligns itself in north-south direction on the earth.
Reason (R): Behaviour of the needle of a compass is same as that of a freely suspended bar magnet.
Options
Assertion (A) is false, but Reason (R) is true.
Quick Oral Answer
No — a compass needle is just a small bar magnet, so it aligns with the strongest magnetic field acting on it. Near earth alone, that is the earth's field, giving north-south alignment. But bring it close to a bar magnet or a current-carrying wire (as the chapter's activities show), and the needle deflects toward that stronger external field instead.
Analysis & Explanation
As per the NCERT chapter, "A compass needle is a small magnet. Its one end, which points towards north, is called a north pole, and the other end, which points towards south, is called a south pole." This makes Reason (R) correct — the compass needle behaves exactly like a freely suspended bar magnet, since it essentially is a small bar magnet.
However, Assertion (A) is false. A compass needle normally aligns itself along the north-south direction only because, in the absence of any nearby magnet or current-carrying conductor, the only magnetic field acting on it is the earth's own magnetic field, and a freely suspended magnet always aligns along the direction of the net magnetic field acting on it. The chapter's activities repeatedly demonstrate this: "Place the compass near the north pole of the magnet. How does it behave? The south pole of the needle points towards the north pole of the magnet..." and "Observe the direction of deflection of the north pole of the needle. If the current flows from north to south... the north pole of the compass needle would move towards the east." These activities show that when a strong external magnetic field (from a bar magnet or a current-carrying wire) is brought near the compass, the needle deflects away from north-south and aligns instead along the direction of the resultant (stronger) external field — it does not stay fixed in the north-south direction. In fact, the chapter notes that increasing the current (i.e., strengthening the external field) increases the deflection: "if the current is increased, the deflection also increases," confirming that a strong external field overrides the earth's field and pulls the needle away from north-south.
Why the other options are wrong:
- Option A is wrong because although R is true, A itself is false, so R cannot be a correct explanation of a false statement.
- Option B is wrong for the same reason — A is not true, so both cannot be true.
- Option C is wrong because it has A and R reversed relative to the actual case; here R (not A) is the true statement, while A is false.
Thus only option D correctly captures that A is false while R is true.
Common Mistakes
- 1Assuming a compass needle always points north-south regardless of nearby magnets, ignoring the deflection activities described in the chapter (near a bar magnet or current-carrying wire).
- 2Confusing 'freely suspended in earth's field alone' with 'in the presence of a strong external field' — the needle's north-south alignment is conditional on there being no stronger competing field nearby.
- 3Marking option A because R sounds like it explains A, without checking that A itself is factually false.
Interesting Facts
The very principle used in the chapter's activities — deflecting a compass needle with a current-carrying wire — is the basis of Oersted's discovery of the magnetic effect of electric current, and also the working principle of a moving-coil galvanometer.
Because a compass responds to the strongest nearby magnetic field, sensitive compasses and magnetometers must be kept away from current-carrying wires and magnets to give a true north-south reading, exactly as illustrated in Activities 12.1 and 12.6 of the chapter.
Spotted a mistake or something unclear?
Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many marks does this question carry in CBSE Class 10 Science 2026?
This question carries 1 mark in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2026 examination.
Which chapter does this question come from in Science?
This question is from the chapter "Magnetic Effects of Electric Current" in the CBSE Class 10 Science syllabus.
What topic does this question cover in Science?
This question covers the topic "Magnetic compass and magnetic field lines" from CBSE Class 10 Science.
Has this question appeared in other CBSE Science papers?
Yes, a similar question appeared in the 2026 CBSE Class 10 Science paper.
What type of question is this in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2026 paper?
This is a MCQ question from Section C in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2026 paper.