Define the term evolution. "Evolution cannot be equated with progress." Justify this statement.
OR
"During the course of evolution, organs or features may be adapted for new functions." Explain this fact by choosing an appropriate example.
Define the term evolution. "Evolution cannot be equated with progress." Justify this statement.
OR
"During the course of evolution, organs or features may be adapted for new functions." Explain this fact by choosing an appropriate example.
Part 1: Definition of Evolution and Justification
Definition of Evolution:
Evolution is the gradual, continuous process of heritable changes in the characteristics of biological populations over successive generations, leading to the origin of new species from pre-existing ones.
Justification: "Evolution cannot be equated with progress"
- Survival of Simpler Forms: Evolution does not lead to the complete elimination of simpler body designs. For example, simple life forms like bacteria, which evolved billions of years ago, still survive and thrive in highly diverse and extreme environments (such as hot springs and deep-sea hydrothermal vents) where complex organisms cannot exist.
- Adaptation to Niches, Not Perfection: Evolution is not a ladder of progress from 'lower' to 'higher' organisms. Instead, it is a branching process of generating diversity and shaping it through environmental selection. Each branch represents an adaptation to a specific environmental niche, rather than an inherent 'improvement' in design.
- No Inherent Superiority: A complex body design is not necessarily 'better' than a simpler one; it is merely a different way of surviving in a particular environment.
OR
Part 2: Adaptation of Features for New Functions
During the course of evolution, a feature or organ that initially developed for a specific function can be modified over generations to perform a completely different function.
Example: Evolution of Feathers
- Initial Function (Insulation): Feathers first evolved in some dinosaurs (which were reptiles) not for flight, but to provide insulation and thermal regulation to keep them warm in cold weather.
- New Function (Flight): Over generations, as these organisms evolved, these feathers were modified and adapted by birds to assist in flight.
- Conclusion: This shows that a physical trait that started with one utility (warmth) was later co-opted and adapted for an entirely different function (flight) during evolutionary history.
Marking Scheme
- 11 Mark: Accurate definition of evolution.
- 22 Marks: Two distinct points justifying why evolution is not progress (e.g., survival of bacteria, adaptation to niches rather than linear improvement).
Hint
For the first part, think about whether simple bacteria are less successful than humans. For the second part, think about how dinosaurs used feathers before birds used them to fly.
Quick Oral Answer
Evolution is the gradual change in heritable traits of a population over generations. It is not progress because simpler organisms like bacteria are still highly successful today. An example of an organ changing function is feathers, which originally evolved in dinosaurs for warmth but were later adapted by birds for flight.
Analysis & Explanation
This question tests the understanding of evolutionary concepts.
- Evolution vs. Progress: Students often mistake evolution as a linear progression towards 'better' or 'more advanced' organisms. However, evolution is branching and non-directional. The survival of ancient, simple organisms like bacteria proves that complexity is not the ultimate goal of evolution; survival in a given environment is.
- Exaptation (Adaptation for new functions): Evolution works on pre-existing structures. Feathers in dinosaurs are a classic example of exaptation, where a structure evolved for thermoregulation was later co-opted for flight in birds. This demonstrates how natural selection repurposes existing variations.
Common Mistakes
- 1Equating evolution with progress and assuming simpler organisms are 'imperfect' or 'less evolved'.
- 2Stating that feathers evolved in birds first, rather than noting their origin in dinosaurs for insulation.
Interesting Facts
Many theropod dinosaurs, including ancestors of the Tyrannosaurus rex, had primitive feathers long before birds took to the skies!
Spotted a mistake or something unclear?
Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many marks does this question carry in CBSE Class 10 Science 2020?
This question carries 3 marks in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2020 examination.
Which chapter does this question come from in Science?
This question is from the chapter "Heredity" in the CBSE Class 10 Science syllabus.
What topic does this question cover in Science?
This question covers the topic "Evolution" from CBSE Class 10 Science.
What type of question is this in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2020 paper?
This is a Short Answer question from Section B in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2020 paper.