Study the different conclusions drawn by students of a class on the basis of observations of preserved / available specimens of plants and animals. I. Potato and sweet potato are analogous organs in plants. II. Wings of insects and wings of birds are homologous organs in animals. III. Wings of insects and wings of bats are analogous organs in animals. IV. Thorns of citrus and tendrils of cucurbita are analogous organs in plants. The correct conclusions are:
Study the different conclusions drawn by students of a class on the basis of observations of preserved / available specimens of plants and animals. I. Potato and sweet potato are analogous organs in plants. II. Wings of insects and wings of birds are homologous organs in animals. III. Wings of insects and wings of bats are analogous organs in animals. IV. Thorns of citrus and tendrils of cucurbita are analogous organs in plants. The correct conclusions are:
Options
The correct option is C (I and III).
Marking Scheme
- 1Identifying that potato and sweet potato are analogous organs due to different structural origins (stem vs. root) but similar functions. (0.5 marks)
- 2Identifying that wings of insects and bats are analogous organs due to different structural designs but similar functions. (0.5 marks)
Hint
Recall that homologous organs share a common structural origin but may perform different functions, whereas analogous organs have different structural origins but perform similar functions.
Quick Oral Answer
Analogous organs are those organs that have different basic structural designs and developmental origins but perform similar functions, such as the wings of a bat and the wings of an insect.
Analysis & Explanation
Let us analyze each statement to determine its correctness:
- Statement I (Potato and sweet potato are analogous organs in plants): This is correct. A potato is a modified underground stem (tuber) while a sweet potato is a modified adventitious root. They have completely different structural origins but perform the same function of food storage. Therefore, they are analogous organs.
- Statement II (Wings of insects and wings of birds are homologous organs in animals): This is incorrect. The wings of insects (composed of thin chitinous membranes) and the wings of birds (composed of bony forelimbs covered with feathers) have different structural designs and origins but perform the same function of flight. Therefore, they are analogous, not homologous.
- Statement III (Wings of insects and wings of bats are analogous organs in animals): This is correct. The wings of insects and bats have different basic anatomical structures and origins but serve the same function (flight).
- Statement IV (Thorns of citrus and tendrils of cucurbita are analogous organs in plants): This is incorrect. Both the thorns of citrus and the tendrils of cucurbita arise from the axillary bud position, meaning they share a common structural origin. Thus, they are homologous organs, even though they perform different functions (protection and climbing, respectively).
Since statements I and III are correct, the correct option is C.
Common Mistakes
- 1Students often confuse homologous and analogous organs. Remember: Homology = Same origin/structure, different function; Analogy = Different origin/structure, same function.
- 2Confusing potato (stem) and sweet potato (root) as homologous because they both store food underground.
Interesting Facts
Though sweet potato and potato look similar and serve the same function of storing starch, they belong to completely different plant families and represent different plant parts (root vs. stem).
Spotted a mistake or something unclear?
Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many marks does this question carry in CBSE Class 10 Science 2013?
This question carries 1 mark in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2013 examination.
Which chapter does this question come from in Science?
This question is from the chapter "Heredity" in the CBSE Class 10 Science syllabus.
What topic does this question cover in Science?
This question covers the topic "Homologous and Analogous Organs" from CBSE Class 10 Science.
What type of question is this in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2013 paper?
This is a MCQ question from Section B in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2013 paper.