Q16
3 marksShort AnswerSection A

Atoms of eight elements A, B, C, D, E, F, G and H have the same number of electronic shells but different number of electrons in their outermost shell. It was found that elements A and G combine to form an ionic compound. This compound is added in a small amount to almost all vegetable dishes during cooking. Oxides of elements A and B are basic in nature while those of E and F are acidic. The oxide of D is almost neutral. Based on the above information answer the following questions : (i) To which group or period of the periodic table do the listed elements belong ? (ii) What would be the nature of compound formed by a combination of elements B and F ? (iii) Which two of these elements could definitely be metals ? (iv) Which one of the eight elements is most likely to be found in gaseous state at room temperature ? (v) If the number of electrons in the outermost shell of elements C and G be 3 and 7 respectively, write the formula of the compound formed by the combination of C and G.

Metals and Non-metals
Chemical Properties of Metals and Non-metals, Oxides, and Periodic Trends
Official Answer

Based on the clues provided, we can systematically identify the elements and answer the questions:


Identification of Elements

  • Elements AA to HH have the same number of electronic shells, meaning they belong to the same period.
  • Elements AA and GG combine to form an ionic compound added to vegetable dishes during cooking, which is Sodium Chloride (NaClNaCl). Thus, AA is Sodium (NaNa) and GG is Chlorine (ClCl).
  • Since NaNa (atomic number 11) and ClCl (atomic number 17) have three shells (K,L,MK, L, M), all these elements belong to Period 3.
  • The elements of Period 3 are:
  • A=NaA = Na (Group 1, 1 valence electron)
  • B=MgB = Mg (Group 2, 2 valence electrons)
  • C=AlC = Al (Group 13, 3 valence electrons)
  • D=SiD = Si (Group 14, 4 valence electrons)
  • E=PE = P (Group 15, 5 valence electrons)
  • F=SF = S (Group 16, 6 valence electrons)
  • G=ClG = Cl (Group 17, 7 valence electrons)
  • H=ArH = Ar (Group 18, 8 valence electrons)



Answers to Sub-questions


(i) Group and Period:

  • All the listed elements belong to Period 3 of the periodic table.
  • Their groups range from Group 1 to Group 18 respectively.

(ii) Nature of compound formed by B and F:

  • Element BB (MgMg, a metal) and Element FF (SS, a non-metal) combine to form Magnesium Sulphide (MgSMgS).
  • The compound is ionic (electrovalent) in nature because it is formed by the transfer of electrons from a metal to a non-metal.

(iii) Two elements that are definitely metals:

  • Elements AA (Sodium) and BB (Magnesium) are definitely metals because they form basic oxides (Na2ONa_2O and MgOMgO).

(iv) Element most likely to be found in gaseous state:

  • Element HH (Argon) is a noble gas and is most likely to be found in the gaseous state at room temperature. (Element GG / Chlorine is also a gas at room temperature).

(v) Formula of compound formed by C and G:

  • Element CC has 3 valence electrons (valency = +3+3).
  • Element GG has 7 valence electrons (valency = 1-1).
  • By crossing over their valencies, the chemical formula of the compound is CG3CG_3 (which corresponds to Aluminium Chloride, AlCl3AlCl_3).
Period 3ionicelectrovalentA and Bbasic oxidesHArgonCG3

Marking Scheme

  • 10.5 marks
  • 20.5 marks
  • 30.5 marks
  • 40.5 marks
  • 51 mark

Hint

Identify the common cooking salt (NaClNaCl) to determine elements A and G. Use their electronic configurations to find the period number (number of shells).

Quick Oral Answer

The compound added to vegetable dishes is Sodium Chloride (NaClNaCl). Sodium belongs to Group 1 and Chlorine belongs to Group 17 of Period 3.

Analysis & Explanation

This question integrates concepts of chemical bonding, oxide nature, and periodic trends.

  1. Oxide Nature: Metals form basic oxides (like Na2ONa_2O and MgOMgO), metalloids form amphoteric/weakly acidic oxides (like SiO2SiO_2), and non-metals form acidic oxides (like P2O5P_2O_5 and SO2SO_2). This confirms the metallic nature of AA and BB.
  2. Valency and Formula: Element CC (Group 13) has 3 valence electrons and loses them to form C3+C^{3+}. Element GG (Group 17) has 7 valence electrons and gains 1 electron to form GG^-. The resulting electrovalent compound has the formula CG3CG_3.

Common Mistakes

  1. 1Writing the formula as C3GC_3G instead of CG3CG_3 due to incorrect valency cross-over.
  2. 2Confusing the period number with the group number.
  3. 3Identifying DD (Silicon) as a metal instead of a metalloid.

Interesting Facts

Sodium chloride (NaClNaCl) is so vital to human physiology that the word 'salary' originates from the Latin word 'salarium', which was money paid to Roman soldiers to buy salt.

Spotted a mistake or something unclear?

Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many marks does this question carry in CBSE Class 10 Science 2010?

This question carries 3 marks in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2010 examination.

Which chapter does this question come from in Science?

This question is from the chapter "Metals and Non-metals" in the CBSE Class 10 Science syllabus.

What topic does this question cover in Science?

This question covers the topic "Chemical Properties of Metals and Non-metals, Oxides, and Periodic Trends" from CBSE Class 10 Science.

What type of question is this in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2010 paper?

This is a Short Answer question from Section A in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2010 paper.