Q19
10 marksShort AnswerSection B

Develop a story in 150-200 words: While coming out of the bank I saw a monkey walking menacingly towards me. I panicked. The monkey snatched my bag and ran up a nearby tree. I...

Writing Skills
Story Writing
Official Answer

The Clever Trade


...I panicked. The monkey snatched my bag and ran up a nearby tree. I stood frozen, watching it perch on a branch, pawing curiously through my belongings — my phone, wallet, and important office files were all inside. Shouting and throwing stones only made it climb higher, clutching the bag tighter.


Then I remembered a vendor nearby selling bananas. I quickly bought a bunch and held it up, calling softly to the monkey. Its eyes lit up with interest. I placed the bananas on the ground beneath the tree and stepped back. Tempted, the monkey climbed down cautiously, dropped my bag, and grabbed the bananas instead, scurrying away contentedly.


Relieved, I picked up my bag and checked its contents — everything was intact. A small crowd that had gathered burst into laughter and applause at the unusual bargain I had struck. As I walked home, I smiled at how a simple bunch of bananas had saved my day, and learnt that patience and quick thinking work far better than panic when facing the unexpected.

monkeysnatchedpanictrick

Marking Scheme

  • 11 mark for Title.
  • 24 marks for Content.
  • 35 marks for Expression (Creativity/Grammar).

Hint

Monkeys often drop things if offered food.

Quick Oral Answer

A narrative describing the clever retrieval of a bag from a monkey.

Analysis & Explanation

This is a creative story-writing question (10 marks) that tests the ability to develop a coherent plot from a given opening line.


Concept

  • Continue the story in first-person, past tense, keeping the tone consistent with the opening (panic → conflict → resolution).
  • A believable plot device (e.g., using food to lure the monkey) should resolve the conflict of the snatched bag.

Key points

  • (i) Title — a short, catchy title reflecting the incident.
  • (ii) Plot development — build rising action (monkey climbs tree with bag), introduce the trick (offering bananas/food), and show the resolution (bag recovered).
  • (iii) Ending — close with a brief reflection or moral drawn from the episode.

Common mistakes

  • Shifting tense or narrative person mid-story.
  • Leaving the bag-recovery unresolved or ending abruptly.
  • Missing the title, or straying outside the 150–200 word limit.

Real-world

  • Mirrors real human–wildlife encounters (e.g., with monkeys in Indian towns) where calm, food-based tactics work better than aggression or panic.

Common Mistakes

  1. 1Abrupt ending.
  2. 2Incorrect tense usage.

Spotted a mistake or something unclear?

Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many marks does this question carry in CBSE Class 10 English (Communicative) 2017?

This question carries 10 marks in the CBSE Class 10 English (Communicative) 2017 examination.

Which chapter does this question come from in English (Communicative)?

This question is from the chapter "Writing Skills" in the CBSE Class 10 English (Communicative) syllabus.

What topic does this question cover in English (Communicative)?

This question covers the topic "Story Writing" from CBSE Class 10 English (Communicative).

What type of question is this in the CBSE Class 10 English (Communicative) 2017 paper?

This is a Short Answer question from Section B in the CBSE Class 10 English (Communicative) 2017 paper.