In some families, either rural or urban, females are tortured for giving birth to a female child. They do not seem to understand the scientific reason behind the birth of a boy or a girl. In fact the mother is not responsible for the sex of the child and it has been genetically proved that the sex of a newborn is determined by what the child inherits from the father. (a) State the basis on which the sex of a newborn baby is determined in humans. (b) Why is the pair of sex chromosomes called a mismatched pair in males? (c) How is the original number of chromosomes present in the parents restored in the progeny? OR (c) Explain by giving two examples of the organisms in which the sex is not genetically determined.
In some families, either rural or urban, females are tortured for giving birth to a female child. They do not seem to understand the scientific reason behind the birth of a boy or a girl. In fact the mother is not responsible for the sex of the child and it has been genetically proved that the sex of a newborn is determined by what the child inherits from the father. (a) State the basis on which the sex of a newborn baby is determined in humans. (b) Why is the pair of sex chromosomes called a mismatched pair in males? (c) How is the original number of chromosomes present in the parents restored in the progeny? OR (c) Explain by giving two examples of the organisms in which the sex is not genetically determined.
(a) Basis of sex determination in humans:
In human beings, the sex of a newborn is genetically determined. It depends entirely on the type of sex chromosome the child inherits from the father:
- All children inherit an chromosome from their mother.
- If a child inherits an chromosome from the father, the child will be a girl ().
- If a child inherits a chromosome from the father, the child will be a boy ().
(b) Mismatched pair of sex chromosomes in males:
In humans, there are perfect pairs of chromosomes. The pair, called the sex chromosomes, is a perfect pair of in females. However, in males, this pair is mismatched because it consists of one normal-sized chromosome and one shorter chromosome ().
(c) Restoration of original chromosome number in progeny:
During sexual reproduction, germ cells (gametes) are formed such that they contain only one chromosome from each pair (a single set of genes). When the male germ cell (sperm) and female germ cell (egg) combine during fertilization, they form a zygote. This fusion restores the normal double set of chromosomes ( pairs of autosomes and pair of sex chromosomes) in the progeny, ensuring the stability of the DNA of the species.
OR
(c) Organisms where sex is not genetically determined:
In some species, sex is determined by non-genetic factors:
- Reptiles (e.g., some turtles/lizards): The temperature at which fertilized eggs are kept determines whether the developing embryo will become male or female.
- Snails: Individuals can change their sex during their lifetime, showing that their sex is not genetically fixed.
Marking Scheme
- 1Part (a): 1.5 marks (0.5 mark for stating genetic determination, 1 mark for explaining X/Y inheritance from father).
- 2Part (b): 1 mark (0.5 mark for mentioning X and Y, 0.5 mark for stating Y is shorter/mismatched).
- 3Part (c): 1.5 marks (0.5 mark for germ cells having one set, 1 mark for fusion/fertilization restoring the diploid number).
- 4OR Part (c): 1.5 marks (0.75 mark for each example with explanation: reptiles/temperature and snails/sex change).
Hint
Remember that mothers always contribute an X chromosome, so the father's contribution is decisive. For the alternative part, think about how temperature or social/individual changes affect sex in reptiles and snails.
Quick Oral Answer
The sex of a child is determined by the father because the father produces two types of gametes: half with an X chromosome and half with a Y chromosome. If an X-bearing sperm fertilizes the egg, it's a girl; if a Y-bearing sperm fertilizes, it's a boy.
Analysis & Explanation
This case-based question tests the understanding of sex determination in humans and other organisms, as well as the mechanism of chromosome restoration.
- Part (a) requires explaining that the father's sperm determines the sex because semen contains X-carrying sperms and Y-carrying sperms, while all eggs carry an X chromosome.
- Part (b) highlights the structural difference between the X and Y chromosomes in males, where Y is significantly shorter, making them a mismatched pair.
- Part (c) explains the reduction division (meiosis) concept in a simplified manner as described in the NCERT text: germ cells take only one chromosome from each pair, and fertilization restores the diploid number.
- The alternative Part (c) tests knowledge of environmental sex determination using reptiles (temperature-dependent) and snails (ability to change sex) as examples directly from the NCERT text.
Common Mistakes
- 1Blaming the mother for the sex of the child due to lack of scientific knowledge.
- 2Confusing the chromosome contribution, thinking both parents contribute to sex determination equally when only the paternal chromosome determines it.
- 3Forgetting that germ cells have only half the number of chromosomes (haploid) before fusion.
Interesting Facts
In humans, the Y chromosome is much smaller than the X chromosome and contains fewer genes, primarily those responsible for male sex development.
In some reptiles, higher incubation temperatures produce females, while in others, they produce males!
Spotted a mistake or something unclear?
Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many marks does this question carry in CBSE Class 10 Science 2023?
This question carries 4 marks in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2023 examination.
Which chapter does this question come from in Science?
This question is from the chapter "Heredity" in the CBSE Class 10 Science syllabus.
What topic does this question cover in Science?
This question covers the topic "Sex Determination" from CBSE Class 10 Science.
What type of question is this in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2023 paper?
This question appears in Section E in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2023 paper.