The most obvious outcome of the reproductive process is the generation of individuals of similar design, but in sexual reproduction they may not be exactly alike. The resemblances as well as differences are marked. The rules of heredity determine the process by which traits and characteristics are reliably inherited. Many experiments have been done to study the rules of inheritance.
(i) Why an offspring of human being is not a true copy of his parents in sexual reproduction ? (1 mark)
(ii) While performing experiments on inheritance in plants, what is the difference between and generation ? (1 mark)
(iii) (A) Why do we say that variations are useful for the survival of a species over time ? (2 marks)
OR
(iii) (B) Study Mendel's cross between two plants with a pair of contrasting characters: (Round Yellow x Wrinkled Green). He observed 4 types of combinations in generation. Which of these were new combinations ? Why do new features which are not present in the parents, appear in generation ? (2 marks)
The most obvious outcome of the reproductive process is the generation of individuals of similar design, but in sexual reproduction they may not be exactly alike. The resemblances as well as differences are marked. The rules of heredity determine the process by which traits and characteristics are reliably inherited. Many experiments have been done to study the rules of inheritance.
(i) Why an offspring of human being is not a true copy of his parents in sexual reproduction ? (1 mark)
(ii) While performing experiments on inheritance in plants, what is the difference between and generation ? (1 mark)
(iii) (A) Why do we say that variations are useful for the survival of a species over time ? (2 marks)
OR
(iii) (B) Study Mendel's cross between two plants with a pair of contrasting characters: (Round Yellow x Wrinkled Green). He observed 4 types of combinations in generation. Which of these were new combinations ? Why do new features which are not present in the parents, appear in generation ? (2 marks)
(i) An offspring of a human being is not a true copy of its parents because sexual reproduction involves the fusion of male and female gametes, meaning both parents contribute practically equal amounts of genetic material (DNA) to the child. Each trait is influenced by both paternal and maternal DNA, and minor inaccuracies in DNA copying along with genetic recombination generate unique variations in the offspring.
(ii) In Mendelian experiments:
- In the (first-generation) progeny, only one of the parental traits (the dominant trait) is expressed, and there are no halfway or mixed characteristics (e.g., all plants are tall).
- In the (second-generation) progeny (obtained by self-pollinating ), the hidden recessive trait also reappears along with the dominant trait in a specific ratio (e.g., tall to short).
(iii) (A) Variations are useful for the survival of a species over time because environmental conditions (like temperature, climate, or resources) change constantly. Depending on the nature of these variations, different individuals will have different survival advantages. For example, in a heat wave, only bacteria that have a variation allowing them to withstand heat will survive, preventing the entire species from being wiped out. Thus, selection of variants by environmental factors forms the basis of evolutionary survival.
OR
(iii) (B) In Mendel's dihybrid cross ():
- The new combinations (recombinants) observed in the generation are Round Green and Wrinkled Yellow.
- New features appear in the generation because the factors (genes) controlling different traits (like seed shape and seed colour) are present on separate independent pieces of DNA called chromosomes. These traits are inherited independently of each other. During gamete formation and subsequent fertilization, these factors recombine freely, giving rise to novel combinations not present in either of the original parental plants.
Marking Scheme
- 1Part (i): Stating that both parents contribute equal genetic material and DNA copying inaccuracies/recombination create variations: 1 mark
- 2Part (ii): Explaining that shows only dominant traits while shows both dominant and recessive traits in a ratio: 1 mark
- 3Part (iii)(A): Explaining that variations provide survival advantages in changing environments with an example (e.g., heat-resistant bacteria): 2 marks
- 4Part (iii)(B) [OR]: Identifying 'Round Green' and 'Wrinkled Yellow' as new combinations (1 mark) and explaining independent inheritance/recombination of chromosomes (1 mark): 2 marks
Hint
For (i), think about how many parents contribute DNA. For (ii), recall which traits are expressed in versus . For (iii)(A), think about a heat wave and bacteria. For (iii)(B), identify the non-parental phenotypes and recall the principle of independent assortment.
Quick Oral Answer
New combinations in a dihybrid cross appear because of the independent assortment of genes. The genes for seed shape and seed colour are located on separate chromosomes and segregate independently during gamete formation.
Analysis & Explanation
This case-based question tests multiple core concepts of heredity from the NCERT textbook:
- Source of Variation: Sexual reproduction combines DNA from two parents, ensuring that offspring inherit a unique combination of genes, making them distinct from both parents.
- vs Generations: In , the recessive allele is masked by the dominant allele. In , selfing allows the recessive allele to pair up ( or ), leading to the reappearance of the recessive phenotype.
- Survival Value of Variations: Environmental selection acts on variations. Without variation, a drastic environmental change could extinguish an entire population.
- Independent Assortment: The appearance of non-parental combinations (Round Green and Wrinkled Yellow) in the generation of a dihybrid cross proves that the genes for seed shape and seed colour segregate and assort independently during meiosis.
Common Mistakes
- 1In (i), students often just write 'due to DNA copying' without mentioning that genetic material comes from two different parents.
- 2In (iii)(B), students sometimes list 'Round Yellow' or 'Wrinkled Green' as new combinations, which are actually the parental combinations.
- 3In (iii)(B), failing to mention 'independent inheritance' or 'independent assortment' as the reason for new combinations.
Interesting Facts
Mendel's law of independent assortment only holds true for genes that are located on different chromosomes or far apart on the same chromosome. If they were close together, they would be 'linked' and would not assort independently, a concept Mendel luckily avoided by choosing traits on different chromosomes!
Spotted a mistake or something unclear?
Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many marks does this question carry in CBSE Class 10 Science 2023?
This question carries 4 marks in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2023 examination.
Which chapter does this question come from in Science?
This question is from the chapter "Heredity" in the CBSE Class 10 Science syllabus.
What topic does this question cover in Science?
This question covers the topic "Rules for the Inheritance of Traits – Mendel's Contributions" from CBSE Class 10 Science.
What type of question is this in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2023 paper?
This question appears in Section E in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2023 paper.