How do Mendel’s experiment show that traits are inherited independently?
How do Mendel’s experiment show that traits are inherited independently?
Mendel demonstrated that traits are inherited independently by performing a dihybrid cross, in which he crossed pea plants differing in two contrasting characteristics: plant height (tall vs. short) and seed shape (round vs. wrinkled).
- F1 Generation:
- He crossed a pure-breeding tall plant with round seeds () and a short plant with wrinkled seeds ().
- The resulting progeny were all tall with round seeds (). This showed that tallness () and round shape () are dominant traits.
- F2 Generation:
- When the plants were self-pollinated to produce the generation, they did not just produce the parental combinations. Instead, they produced four distinct phenotypes in a ratio of approximately :
- Parental combinations: Tall-Round () and Short-Wrinkled ()
- New combinations (Recombinants): Tall-Wrinkled () and Short-Round ()
- Conclusion:
- The appearance of completely new combinations (such as tall plants with wrinkled seeds and short plants with round seeds) proves that the trait for plant height and the trait for seed shape are inherited completely independently of each other. The factors (genes) controlling these traits assort independently during gamete formation.
Marking Scheme
- 11 Mark: For describing the cross between parents with two contrasting traits (e.g., Tall-Round Short-Wrinkled ) to produce all Tall-Round () in the generation.
- 21 Mark: For explaining the self-pollination of plants and stating the phenotypes obtained in the generation, specifically highlighting the appearance of new recombinant combinations (Tall-Wrinkled and Short-Round).
- 31 Mark: For concluding that the independent assortment of these traits shows they are controlled by separate factors (genes) and are inherited independently.
Hint
Think about Mendel's dihybrid cross involving two traits at once (height and seed shape) and look for the appearance of new, non-parental combinations in the generation.
Quick Oral Answer
Mendel showed independent inheritance using a dihybrid cross of pea plants with two traits: height and seed shape. In the generation, he observed new combinations like tall-wrinkled and short-round in a ratio, proving that the two traits are inherited independently.
Analysis & Explanation
In a dihybrid cross, the independent assortment of alleles occurs because the genes for seed shape and plant height are located on different chromosomes (or far apart on the same chromosome). During meiosis, the segregation of alleles for one gene is completely independent of the segregation of alleles for another gene, leading to the classic phenotypic ratio in the generation.
Common Mistakes
- 1Confusing the monohybrid ratio (3:1) with the dihybrid ratio (9:3:3:1).
- 2Failing to mention the new recombinant combinations (Tall-Wrinkled and Short-Round) which are the actual proof of independent inheritance.
Interesting Facts
Mendel was lucky that the seven traits he chose in pea plants were either on different chromosomes or so far apart on the same chromosome that they behaved as if they were on different chromosomes, allowing him to discover the Law of Independent Assortment without the complication of gene linkage.
Spotted a mistake or something unclear?
Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many marks does this question carry in CBSE Class 10 Science 2016?
This question carries 3 marks in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2016 examination.
Which chapter does this question come from in Science?
This question is from the chapter "Heredity" in the CBSE Class 10 Science syllabus.
What topic does this question cover in Science?
This question covers the topic "Rules for the Inheritance of Traits – Mendel's Contributions" from CBSE Class 10 Science.
Has this question appeared in other CBSE Science papers?
Yes, a similar question appeared in the 2016 CBSE Class 10 Science paper.
What type of question is this in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2016 paper?
This is a Short Answer question from Section A in the CBSE Class 10 Science 2016 paper.