OR
(B) OOP : I haven't a clue. I've been to seven galaxies, but I've never seen anything like this. Maybe they're hats. (He opens a book and puts it on his head.) Say, maybe this is a haberdashery!
OMEGA : (bowing low) Perhaps the Great and Mighty Think-Tank will give us the benefit of his thought on the matter.
THINK-TANK : Elementary, my dear Omega. Hold one of the items up so that I may view it closely. (Omega holds a book on the palm of her hand.) Yes, yes, I understand now. Since Earth creatures are always eating, the place in which you find yourselves is undoubtedly a crude refreshment stand.
OMEGA : (to Iota and Oop) He says we're in a refreshment stand.
OOP : Well, the Earthlings certainly have a strange diet.
(The Book that Saved the Earth)
OR
(B) OOP : I haven't a clue. I've been to seven galaxies, but I've never seen anything like this. Maybe they're hats. (He opens a book and puts it on his head.) Say, maybe this is a haberdashery!
OMEGA : (bowing low) Perhaps the Great and Mighty Think-Tank will give us the benefit of his thought on the matter.
THINK-TANK : Elementary, my dear Omega. Hold one of the items up so that I may view it closely. (Omega holds a book on the palm of her hand.) Yes, yes, I understand now. Since Earth creatures are always eating, the place in which you find yourselves is undoubtedly a crude refreshment stand.
OMEGA : (to Iota and Oop) He says we're in a refreshment stand.
OOP : Well, the Earthlings certainly have a strange diet.
(The Book that Saved the Earth)
This is Option (B), an alternative extract from the comic science-fiction play The Book That Saved the Earth by Claire Boiko. In this scene, Martian explorers — Oop, Omega, and their leader Think-Tank — have landed in a library on Earth and are utterly baffled by books, first mistaking them for hats (Oop jokingly calls the place a 'haberdashery'), and then, based on Think-Tank's confidently wrong 'expert' deduction, taking the library itself for a 'crude refreshment stand', reasoning simply that 'Earth creatures are always eating.' The humour comes entirely from the gap between the Martians' overblown self-assurance and their completely mistaken conclusions about ordinary human objects — a satire of unearned authority and blind trust in a supposed expert's word. Students choosing Option (B) must answer ALL of the sub-questions set on this extract instead of on Option (A).
Marking Scheme
- 1This passage itself carries no independent marks; its 5 marks would be distributed across four sub-questions (I–IV) in the same pattern as Option (A): 1+2+1+1 = 5 marks.
- 2Full marks require the candidate to answer only the sub-questions belonging to the extract they select (A or B), not both.
Hint
Choose only ONE extract, (A) or (B), and answer all of its sub-questions consistently; do not attempt both.
Quick Oral Answer
This is the extract for Option (B) — a comic scene from The Book That Saved the Earth where Martians mistake books for hats and then for food, showing the playwright's humour and satire on false expertise.
Analysis & Explanation
This extract from the comic sci-fi play 'The Book That Saved the Earth' (First Flight) shows Martians hilariously misinterpreting ordinary Earth objects.
Concept
- Martians planning to invade Earth in 2040 are baffled by books, mistaking them first for hats, then — via Think-Tank's confident but wrong deduction — for a 'refreshment stand', since 'Earth creatures are always eating'.
Key points
- Think-Tank's pompous, Sherlock-Holmes-style 'Elementary, my dear Omega' mocks know-it-all authority figures who reach absurd conclusions with total confidence.
- The comedy relies on dramatic irony: the reader knows the objects are books while the characters confidently reach illogical conclusions, satirising blind faith in claimed 'expertise'.
Common mistakes (exam caution)
- As with Option (A), candidates must select only ONE extract and answer all of its sub-questions; attempting both wastes time and only the chosen extract's answers are evaluated.
Common Mistakes
- 1Attempting sub-questions from both extract (A) and extract (B) instead of selecting only one.
- 2Missing the humour/irony of the scene and reading it only literally, without noticing the satire on false expertise.
- 3Confusing character names — Think-Tank is the pompous 'expert' leader; Oop and Omega are the exploring Martians who report to him.
Interesting Facts
'The Book That Saved the Earth' by Claire Boiko is set in the year 2040 and imagines Martians preparing to invade Earth after Earth's own population has moved to other planets.
The character Think-Tank's dramatic 'Elementary, my dear Omega' line is a direct parody of Sherlock Holmes's catchphrase 'Elementary, my dear Watson.'
The play's central comic irony is that a simple children's picture book (Mother Goose rhymes) ultimately confuses the invading Martians so much that it saves Earth from invasion.
Spotted a mistake or something unclear?
Tell us — we fix reported answers fast.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to answer sub-questions on both extracts?
No. You choose ANY ONE of the two given extracts, (A) or (B), and answer only its sub-questions.
Who is Think-Tank in this play?
Think-Tank is the pompous, self-assured Martian leader who confidently but wrongly interprets Earth objects, such as mistaking a library for a refreshment stand.